Thinking about adding an Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) to your property? It’s a smart move! ADUs are becoming super popular because they offer a great way to make the most of your space. I’ve seen these handy additions provide rental income, give families more room, or just make the house more spacious. But here’s the big question: should you convert your garage or build a new ADU from scratch?
Most homeowners opt to convert their garage rather than build a detached or attached ADU. Why? Mainly because garage conversions are often much more affordable. To give you an idea, converting a garage costs between $50 and $100 per square foot. On the other hand, building a new ADU can set you back between $200 and $400 per square foot. That’s a huge difference!
Let’s break it down:
Costs and Benefits
Garage Conversion
- Cost: $50 – $100 per square foot
- Speed: Faster completion times
- Benefits: Lower cost, quicker to finish
- Considerations: Limited to existing garage size and structure
New Construction ADU
- Cost: $200 – $400 per square foot
- Speed: Takes longer to build
- Benefits: Customizable design, more flexibility
- Considerations: Higher cost, longer build time
Permitting and Professional Help
No matter which option you choose, you’ll need to get the right permits. This can be a bit of a headache, so it’s really important to work with experienced ADU professionals who know the ropes. They can help you avoid common pitfalls and ensure your project runs smoothly.
Return on Investment
Both options can be great investments. A well-done ADU can increase your property value and offer rental income. Garage conversions usually cost less upfront, which means you might see a return on your investment faster. But new constructions, though pricier, can add more space and potentially higher rental income.
Download FREE ADU Guidebook
The ADU Guidebook will give you full information on all steps of a successful ADU development.
Garage Conversions: An Overview
Thinking about turning your garage into a livable ADU? It’s a popular choice and a great way to add space and value to your home. But before you jump in, here’s a look at what’s involved.
Steps in a Garage Conversion
- Assessment and Planning: First off, you need to figure out if your garage can be converted. This means checking if it’s suitable and planning the layout. You might want to hire an architect or designer to draw up detailed plans and ensure everything meets local building codes and zoning rules.
- Obtaining Permits: Getting the necessary permits is a must. This can take anywhere from a few weeks to a few months, depending on where you live. A permit expeditor can help speed things up and keep your project on track.
- Structural Modifications: Turning a garage into a living space often means making big changes. This could include reinforcing the foundation, adding insulation, and installing windows and doors. Make sure to hire a licensed contractor experienced with ADUs to get the job done right.
- Utilities Installation: You’ll need plumbing, electrical wiring, and heating/cooling systems. This part can be tricky and pricey, usually costing between $5,000 and $10,000. Licensed professionals are essential here.
- Interior Finishing: After the structural work and utilities are sorted, it’s time to finish the interior. Think drywall, flooring, and fixtures. This is where you can really personalize the space. Expect to spend between $5,000 and $15,000 on this step.
Key Considerations
- Local Zoning Regulations: Check your local zoning laws. Some areas have specific rules about ADUs, like minimum lot sizes or parking requirements. Research these before starting your project.
- Condition of the Existing Garage: If your garage is in rough shape, the costs can add up fast. A thorough assessment will help you understand what’s needed.
- Potential Structural Modifications: Depending on your garage’s age and condition, you might need significant structural upgrades, like a new foundation, roof improvements, or wall reinforcements.
Popularity and Trends
Despite the challenges, garage conversions are a top choice for many homeowners. Although there are no hard statistics on how many ADU’s are garage conversions, the popularity of garage conversions as ADUs is consistently emphasized in various housing and urban development reports, particularly in regions with supportive ADU policies and high housing demand.
New Construction ADUs: An Overview
Building a new construction ADU means starting from scratch to create a separate living space on your property. It’s an exciting project that allows for a lot of customization, but it also involves several steps and considerations. Here’s a look at what’s involved.
Steps in Building a New Construction ADU
- Design and Planning: The first step is designing the ADU and creating detailed architectural plans. This is your chance to get creative and tailor the space to your needs. An experienced architect or designer can help ensure your plans are practical and meet all local building codes and zoning rules.
- Permitting: Getting the necessary permits is crucial. New construction ADUs often require more permits than garage conversions because you’re building a new structure. This process can take several months and cost between $2,000 and $5,000, depending on your location and project complexity.
- Site Preparation: Once you have your permits, it’s time to prepare the site. This includes clearing the land, grading, and laying the foundation. Site preparation costs can range from $10,000 to $30,000, depending on your property’s condition.
- Construction: With the site ready, construction begins. This is usually the most time-consuming and expensive part, with costs ranging from $70,000 to $200,000 or more, depending on the ADU’s size and complexity. Hiring a licensed general contractor with ADU experience is essential to ensure quality work.
- Utilities Installation: You’ll need plumbing, electrical, and HVAC systems. This can be pricey, often costing between $10,000 and $30,000, depending on how far the new ADU is from the main house.
- Interior Finishing: Once the structure is up, it’s time to finish the interior with drywall, flooring, cabinetry, and fixtures. This is another chance to customize the space. Interior finishing costs can range from $10,000 to $35,000 or more.
- Inspection and Approval: The final step is passing all inspections and getting approval from your local building department. This ensures your ADU meets all safety and quality standards and is ready for use.
Key Considerations
- Local Zoning Regulations: Make sure to research your local zoning laws. Some areas have specific rules about ADUs that could affect your project.
- Condition of the Site: Preparing the site can be costly, especially if your property needs a lot of work to get ready for construction.
Popularity and Trends
New construction ADUs offer more flexibility in design and can be larger than garage conversions. Although they come with higher costs and longer timelines, they can be a fantastic investment. Typically, new construction ADUs take 6-12 months from start to finish. According to a case study done by Villa, ADUs can offer a significant return on investment, with rental income often covering the construction and financing costs.
Cost Comparison: Garage Conversion vs. New Construction
Deciding between a garage conversion and a new construction ADU often comes down to cost. Here’s a detailed look at the typical expenses for each option.
Garage Conversions
Typical Costs: Garage conversions generally range from $20,000 to $50,000, depending on the size of the garage and the extent of renovations needed.
- Permits: $1,000 – $3,000
- Structural Work: $5,000 – $15,000
- Utilities: $5,000 – $10,000
- Interior Finishing: $5,000 – $15,000
The average cost per square foot for a garage conversion is between $50 and $100. For a 400-square-foot garage conversion, you can expect to pay between $20,000 and $40,000.
New Construction ADUs
Typical Costs: New construction ADUs generally range from $100,000 to $300,000 or more, depending on the size and complexity of the project.
Cost Breakdown:
- Permits: $2,000 – $5,000
- Site Preparation: $10,000 – $30,000
- Construction: $70,000 – $200,000
- Utilities: $10,000 – $30,000
- Interior Finishing: $10,000 – $35,000
The average cost per square foot for new construction ADUs is between $200 and $400. For a 600-square-foot ADU, you can expect to pay between $120,000 and $240,000.
Factors Affecting Costs
- Location: Costs can vary significantly based on where you live. Construction costs and permit fees differ from city to city.
- Materials: The choice of materials, finishes, and fixtures can greatly impact the overall cost.
- Complexity: More complex designs or challenging site conditions can increase costs.
- Contractor: The choice of contractor can also affect costs. Experienced or in-demand contractors often charge higher rates.
Long-term Costs and Potential Returns
Beyond the initial construction costs, it’s important to consider ongoing maintenance and utility expenses. These might be higher for new construction ADUs due to their larger size and complexity. However, new construction ADUs can offer higher rental income and greater property value appreciation over time.
Garage Conversions vs. New Construction ADUs: Pros and Cons
When it comes to adding an ADU to your property, you have two main options: converting an existing garage or building a new structure. Each has its own benefits and drawbacks. Let’s break them down.
Free ADU Cost Calculator
Garage Conversions
Benefits:
- Lower Costs: Garage conversions are generally much cheaper, costing between $20,000 and $50,000.
- Quicker to Complete: These projects are faster since they involve working with an existing structure. Most garage conversions take 2-3 months, compared to 6-12 months for new construction.
- Utilizes Existing Space: Converting a garage makes use of space that might otherwise be underused, without taking up additional yard space or altering your property’s exterior.
Drawbacks:
- Limited Space: Garages are typically smaller than new construction ADUs, which can limit living space. This might not be ideal for larger families or those needing more room.
- Potential Zoning Issues: Some cities have strict zoning requirements for ADUs that can complicate or even prevent a garage conversion. Research your local laws before starting.
- Structural Modifications: Older garages might need significant upgrades to meet building codes, which can add to the overall cost and timeline.
New Construction ADUs
Benefits:
- Greater Design Flexibility: Building from scratch means you can design the space to your exact specifications and needs.
- Increased Living Space: New constructions are typically larger, providing more room for family or tenants.
- Higher Rental Income: Because new ADUs are often bigger and more customized, they can command higher rental rates, offering a better return on investment over time.
Drawbacks:
- Higher Costs: New construction ADUs are much more expensive, ranging from $100,000 to $300,000 or more.
- Longer Construction Timeline: Building a new ADU takes more time, usually between 6-12 months. This can be a downside if you need the space quickly.
- Complex Permitting Process: Since you’re building a new structure, the permitting process is more involved and time-consuming, adding to the overall cost and timeline.
Garage Conversion Example
Let’s take a look at a recent project in San Diego where a homeowner decided to convert their 400-square-foot garage into a one-bedroom ADU. The main goal was to create a cozy living space for their aging parents while boosting their property’s value.
The project involved:
- Reinforcing the existing foundation
- Adding insulation and drywall
- Installing a small kitchenette and bathroom
- Adding new windows and a separate entrance for privacy and natural light
Total Cost: $35,000
- Permits and fees: $2,500
- Structural work and insulation: $10,000
- Plumbing and electrical: $8,000
- Interior finishes and appliances: $12,000
- Exterior improvements (paint, landscaping): $2,500
Timeline: About 3 months
Outcome: The homeowner was thrilled. The ADU provided a comfortable, private space for their parents and increased the property’s rental potential and overall value.
New Construction ADU Example
Now, let’s look at a project in Santa Cruz where a family decided to build a new detached ADU in their backyard for rental income. With a bigger budget, they wanted to maximize the unit’s size and amenities.
The project involved designing a 600-square-foot ADU with:
- A full kitchen
- Living room
- Bedroom
- Bathroom
- Small outdoor patio
- Separate laundry facilities
Total Cost: $200,000
- Permits and fees: $4,000
- Site preparation and foundation: $25,000
- Framing and roofing: $50,000
- Plumbing and electrical: $30,000
- Interior finishes and appliances: $70,000
- Exterior improvements (siding, landscaping): $21,000
Timeline: About 8 months
Outcome: Despite the higher cost and longer timeline, the family was very happy. The spacious, modern ADU commanded a high rental rate, providing a steady income stream.
Conclusion
Garage conversions are generally more affordable and quicker to complete, while new constructions offer more space, amenities, and rental potential.
The best choice depends on your specific needs, budget, and long-term goals. Always work with experienced ADU professionals to guide you through the process for a successful outcome. So, what’s your plan? Ready to turn that dusty garage into a cozy living space, or do you have your sights set on building a brand-new ADU?
